Short Read :
Mint Vs YNAB – Controlling your financial expenses and achieving your financial goals is an important aspect of personal finance. There are many budgeting tools available in the market that can help you with this task. Two popular products that are often compared are Mint and YNAB. After analyzing both of these products, I have come to a final verdict.
MINT
IDEAL FOR BEGINNERS
Mint is a personal finance software that is completely free and offers a range of services in addition to budgeting. It allows users to manage their finances using one platform, which can track bills and subscriptions to help identify areas of excess spending. Additionally, Mint provides a BillShark service that helps negotiate bills in order to reduce expenses. It is more than just a budgeting tool and aims to address various personal financial management issues.
Supported Platform
Android
IOS
WEB
APPLE WATCH
ALEXA
Price: Free (With Ads), $4.99 (Without Ads + additional features -Only for IOS Users)
Key Features:
- All accounts in one place – Allows you to integrate your investments account as well.
- Credit Score.
- Subscription Management.
- Bill negotiation.
YNAB
IDEAL FOR SEASONED BUDGET PLANNERS
YNAB is a paid app designed to assist individuals with managing their finances by creating a detailed budget and allocating every dollar earned to a specific bucket. It has all the essential features that a budgeting app.
Supported Platform
Android
IOS
WEB
APPLE WATCH
ALEXA
Price: $99 USD/Year, first 34 days free.
Key Features:
- You have the option to connect your bank accounts, or you can manually input transactions if you prefer.
- Prioritize budgeting over just tracking expenses.
- You can create categories from scratch using the highly flexible user interface.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | YNAB | MINT | Feature | YNAB | MINT |
| Expense Tracking | Yes | Yes | Security | Yes | Yes |
| Income Tracking | Yes | Yes | Mobile Accessibility | Yes | Yes |
| Budget Creation | Yes | Yes | Data Export | Yes | Yes |
| Expense Categories | Yes | Yes | Debt Tracking | Yes | Partial |
| Bill Reminders | Workaround | Yes | Investment Tracking | Yes | Partial |
| Goal Setting | Yes | Yes | Tax Planning | Yes | Yes |
| Financial Reports | Yes | Yes | Multi-Currency Support | Workaround | No |
| Transaction History | Yes | Yes | User-Friendly Interface | Yes | Yes |
| Bank Account Integration | Yes | Yes | Customization | Yes | No |
| Manual Transaction | Yes | Partial | Savings Goals | Yes | Yes |
| Customer Support | Yes | Yes | Collaboration | Yes | No |
| Below is the list of essential sub-features of Personal Finance Software | |||||
| Sub-Feature | YNAB | MINT | Sub-Feature | YNAB | MINT |
| Net Worth | Yes | Yes | Planning Different Scenarios | No | No |
| Budget Calendar | Yes | No | Flexible budgeting (Any date range) | Yes | No |
| Label Transactions automatically | Yes | Yes | Create Custom Dashboards/Reports | Yes | No |
| Transaction Search | Yes | Yes | Cashflow Forecasting | Workaround | No |
| Migrating from Other Budget Apps | Workaround | No | |||
Verdict
Both tools are really powerful in many ways. If you’re looking to take control of your spending and manage your budget effectively, YNAB is a great choice.
In my analysis, I have found that Mint is an excellent tool for tracking and managing your expenses. Unlike YNAB, it does not require you to be more organized. If you prefer a more hands-off approach and want to do ad-hoc budgeting and tracking, then Mint is a good place to start. It allows you to put things on autopilot while still keeping an eye on your finances.